The Bangladesh government is considering a proposal from China on the management and restoration of the Teesta river, the fourth longest river in the country that flows down from India.
The Chinese proposal comes as Bangladesh has spent almost a decade trying to finalise a water sharing deal with India on the Teesta river. The signing of the deal was postponed at the last moment in 2011 due to opposition from Mamata Banerjee, the chief minister of West Bengal, India. Bangladesh has made no progress through negotiations with India since then.
Meanwhile, Bangladesh has seen water levels in the Teesta drop dramatically in recent years during the dry season, due to dam construction and irrigation canals upstream and the impacts of climate change – further straining relations with India.
In the dry season, farmers can no longer grow their crops. In 2016, the water flow fell to 300 cusecs in the dry season – over twenty times less than two decades ago.
The new China backed Teesta river management and restoration project offers hope for the people living in the northern region of Bangladesh, who face floods and erosion during the monsoon and severe water shortages during the dry season.
“We got an offer from [the Chinese]. Now we need to sit with them to set down the terms and conditions before finalising the deal,” Kabir Bin Anwar, senior secretary in the ministry of water resources, told The Third Pole.
Taming the Teesta river
Last July, the Ministry of Water Resources sought a USD 983 million loan from China to implement the “Teesta River Comprehensive Management and Restoration project’”, in a letter to Bangladesh’s Economic Relations Division.
The Bangladesh government will bear 15% of total project cost (about USD 130 million) and the rest will come a Chinese loan.
The river is braided – a network of small channels and islands – created by the vast amounts of sediment carried down from the Himalayas every year, which builds up on the riverbed. This causes frequent floods and severe river bank erosion during the monsoon, while the basin faces water shortages during the dry season.
Every year, thousands of people lose their lands, homesteads and livelihoods.
The Bangladesh Water Development Board and Power Construction Corporation of China (Power China), a state-owned enterprise, signed a non-binding memorandum of understanding for this project on 28 September 2016.
Since then, Power China has submitted a masterplan and a feasibility study for the project. The summary of the preliminary project proposal attached with the letter, describes its scope.
The plan is to build over 100km of embankments along both sides of the river, from upstream of the Teesta barrage near the border with India to the confluence with the Brahmaputra.
The project includes engineering measures to protect the riverbanks and prevent erosion by building groynes, cross bars and levees.
On top of this, the project will involve dredging and deepening 110 km of the Teesta for inland navigation.
These measures will stabilise the movement of the river and force its flow into a narrower main channel, say the project report and a promotional video. It also aims to increase water availability by building a network of canals and ponds to store monsoon rains for the dry season.
Dredged material will be used to reclaim land. Roads, satellite towns and industrial parks will be built along the riverbanks, including garment processing factories and fertiliser plants.
The Teesta irrigation project
Bangladesh’s Ministry of Water Resources hopes the project will improve agricultural output in the Teesta river basin.
“If we can implement the project, a vast area on the Bangladesh side can be supplied with water during the crisis season,” senior secretary Anwar told the local media.
Currently, the northern parts of Bangladesh face severe water crisis for at least two months a year because of low water flow in the Teesta. Most of the 111,000 hectares of irrigable land in the Teesta basin in Bangladesh is uncultivable during this period due to lack of water. In 2013-14 only 35% of the total irrigable area was cultivated.
In 1997 water flow of Teesta in Bangladesh was nearly 6,500 cusecs during dry season . But in 2006, its flow fell to 1,348 cusec and in 2016 during the dry period it was only 300 cusecs.
The PDPP says that among other aspects, the project will focus on transportation and shipping and mitigate social and environmental impact, restore ecosystems and promote local socio-economic development. But there are no details of these impacts in the proposal.
Project proponents say it will boost the local economy and promote green development. Last month, Power China signed an EPC contract to develop 500 MW of solar and wind energy in Bangladesh, the largest ever addition of renewable capacity in the country.
Environmental impacts unclear
But there are reasons to be cautious, warned Syeda Rizwana Hasan, head of the Bangladesh Environmental Lawyers’ Association (BELA). The details of the proposed structural interventions and terms of the loans are still unknown and have not been publicly debated. Hence it is unclear how environmentally sustainable the project is, she pointed out.
Some experts are sceptical of the success of the Chinese-led plan.
Monsur Rahman, pprofessor at the Institute of Water and Flood Management (IWFM), Bangladesh University of Engineering and Technology (BUET), said he doubts whether it will be possible to make the project successful as the characteristic of the Teesta river are very complex.
It would be easier to build a barrage to retain water, said Rahman, an expert who has been involved in the Delta Plan 2100 – Bangladesh’s long term plan to boost its economy and deal with climate change.
“The river has a braided characteristic [with multiple rivulets and islands] that has developed over thousands of years. So it will be a continuous struggle to keep the Teesta in a narrow single channel,” he said. Currently the Teesta riverbed is five to six km wide, and the plans would force the river into a deeper one km wide channel.
In response to this observation, project director Chowdhury said they have sought the advice a number of consultants before making the initial reports.
Ainun Nishat, the doyen of river experts in Bangladesh, said it is hard to say whether the project will be successful or not, as adequate studies have not been conducted on the river.
“If they want to hold the monsoon water in the river after dredging, they need to build a structure downstream of the Teesta. So before making any comment we need to know more what they are planning to construct and how they are going to do it,” Nishat said.
Fear of debt trap
The project has powerful proponents, but many experts and members of the civil society want the Bangladesh government to assess the Chinese terms and conditions properly before going ahead. There are concerns that Chinese financial assistance may have harsh economic and geopolitical implications. Project supporters say fears of a Chinese “debt trap” have been overplayed.
Bangladesh is currently seeking Chinese funding for nine development projects worth USD 6 billion, including the first phase of Payra seaport, the Barisal-Bhola bridge and a technology park.
During Chinese President Xi Jinping’s visit to Dhaka in 2016, the two countries signed MoUs for projects worth over USD 25 billion.
Transboundary river politics
Hasan of BELA said Bangladesh needs to defend its rights over transboundary rivers. Undoubtedly, India has been insensitive to the legitimate claims of Bangladesh over shared rivers including the Teesta, she held. “They have kept the decision over Teesta water sharing hanging for more than a decade pleading state level objection.”
It is the first time China has become involved in a river management project in Bangladesh, a country that shares 54 rivers with India. The Teesta region is strategically important and in India, many see this project as an opportunity for China to gain an advantage over its regional rival.
This is happening at a time when tensions are high between India and China, which is pursuing its Belt and Road initiative to build ‘better’ connectivity and cement its influence in the region.
After news of Chinese investment in the Teesta management project broke out in the Bangladesh media, New Delhi sent its foreign secretary Harsh Vardhan Shringla to Dhaka.
However, there was no public confirmation whether Shringla had raised the issue during his talks. In the Bangladesh capital Dhaka, members of the Bangladesh-India Joint River Commission confirmed that India has not initiated any talks on water sharing since Shringla’s visit.